Mayhill, NM Real Estate Search

Mayhill Homes for Sale

Our website features the best Mayhill real estate search for homes available. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Mayhill Homes for Sale

Avg. No of Beds
Avg. No of Baths
Avg. Living Ft2
Avg. Listing Price
Cost per ft2
Days on Market

Curious about what’s happening in the Mayhill real estate market? Sign up for a  Mayhill Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Mayhill Homes for Sale

$259,900
2 Beds 1 Baths 172973 MLS
Quintessential Mountain Retreat – Turn-Key & Ready to Enjoy Escape to the cool mountains with this charming, fully furnished cabin located just 8.5 miles from Cloudcroft. Nestled on a spacious 0.459-acre lot, this move-in-ready mountain home offers the perfect blend of comfort, convenience, and rustic charm. The property features a large circular driveway with ample parking for multiple vehicles, including room for a truck and trailer. A garage beneath the home provides the ideal space for storing your mountain toys, whether it's a side-by-side, ATV, or outdoor gear. This well-maintained cabin has been thoughtfully updated throughout. The interior and exterior have been freshly painted, and the roof was replaced in October 2024, offering peace of mind for years to come. Inside, you'll find a warm and inviting living space highlighted by beautifully refinished hardwood floors and a host of new upgrades, including a refrigerator, range, microwave/vent hood, and water heater. New French doors open onto a spacious covered wraparound deck, creating the perfect setting to relax with your morning coffee, entertain friends, or simply take in the fresh mountain air. The home offers two comfortable bedrooms and a charming bathroom featuring a classic claw-foot tub with shower, adding timeless character to this cozy retreat. Whether you're searching for a full-time residence, a weekend getaway, or a vacation rental investment, this cabin checks all the boxes. Being sold furnished and truly turn-key, all you need to do is bring your suitcase and start enjoying mountain life. Properties like this are hard to find and don't stay on the market long. Schedule your private showing today and claim your own piece of the Sacramento Mountains, where cool summers, fresh air, and year-round adventure await.

4 Sherwood Forest, Mayhill

$3,200,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 172965 MLS
High Country Horse Ranch & Arena. Live Water • Irrigated Meadows • Premier Equestrian Facilities • Income Potential Welcome to High Country Horse Ranch & Arena, a remarkable New Mexico equestrian estate where exceptional horse facilities, live water, and breathtaking mountain scenery come together to create a truly one-of-a-kind property. Whether you're looking for a private horse ranch, an event facility, a boarding operation, or an investment with multiple income streams, this turnkey ranch offers endless possibilities. Teeming with life, the vibrant Rio Peñasco winds through the ranch, providing year-round live water that nourishes lush irrigated meadows while creating outstanding habitat for fish, waterfowl, elk, deer, turkey, and a variety of native wildlife. The ranch includes valuable water rights and is further supported by two productive water wells, ensuring dependable water for the ranch, livestock, equestrian facilities, and the established RV park. Bordering the majority of the ranch, the Lincoln National Forest offers direct access to miles of scenic mountain trails, making this an exceptional destination for trail riding, hiking, hunting, and year-round outdoor recreation in the majestic Sacramento Mountains. Located within the highly sought-after Game Management Unit 34, the property has historically received two elk tags, making it equally attractive to sportsmen and outdoor enthusiasts. At the heart of the ranch stands an outstanding 295' × 175' covered equestrian complex, encompassing approximately 51,625 square feet. Inside is a spacious 170' × 120' arena with premium sand footing designed for multi-event use, providing an ideal environment for training, competitions, clinics, and recreational riding regardless of the weather. The horse facilities have been thoughtfully designed for efficiency and comfort and include: •16 covered box stalls •Rubber mat flooring •Priefert feeding system •Wash rack •Horse stocks •Tack storage •Hay and feed storage •Five arena-adjacent livestock holding pens •Loafing sheds •Lighted 60-foot round pen This ranch property also features a well-maintained three-bedroom, two-bath manager's home with an attached two-car garage and workshop. Also included are painted pipe cattle working pens complete with squeeze chute trailer load-out. Multiple elevated homesites throughout the ranch provide outstanding opportunities to build a custom residence overlooking the river, meadows, and surrounding mountains.

3705 US Hwy 82, Mayhill

$219,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 172899 MLS
Mountain Retreat with Modern Updates – Perfect for Retirement or a Summer Getaway Escape to the cool mountain air and enjoy the peaceful lifestyle you've been dreaming of in this updated 2-bedroom, 2-bath mountain home situated on a spacious 0.78-acre lot just 13 miles east of Cloudcroft. Offering 1,280 square feet of living space, this charming home has been thoughtfully updated throughout. Fresh interior paint, new flooring, updated electrical and plumbing systems, an updated septic system, and a new on-demand propane water heater provide peace of mind and modern convenience. The open-concept great room features a cathedral ceiling, large windows that bring the outdoors in, ceiling fans, and both a cozy wood stove and propane heat for year-round comfort. The spacious kitchen offers room for cooking, and gathering with family and friends. The main bedroom has an ensuite bathroom, while the second full bath has been completely remodeled with a beautiful walk-in shower. A convenient laundry area adds everyday functionality and ease. Step outside to enjoy the covered porch, fenced yard, and nearly three-quarters of an acre of mountain property with plenty of space. Whether you're looking for a retirement retreat, a summer vacation cabin, or a full-time mountain residence, this property delivers the perfect blend of rustic charm and modern amenities. Stay connected with high-speed 100 Mbps fiber optic internet already wired to the home, making remote work, streaming, and communication effortless. Don't miss this opportunity to own your own mountain escape where cool summers, star-filled nights, and peaceful living await. Owner financing is available with acceptable terms

10 Circle DR, Mayhill

$125,000
2 Beds 1 Baths 172810 MLS
Rustic Mountain Cabin with Endless Potential on .722 Acres Tucked away at the end of a quiet road in the beautiful Sacramento Mountains, this charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath cabin offers a rare opportunity to create your ideal mountain retreat. Set on approximately .722 acres and conveniently located just 10 miles from Cloudcroft and 7 miles from Mayhill, the property combines peaceful seclusion with easy access to local amenities and outdoor recreation. Perfect for those with a vision, this handyman special provides the ideal canvas to restore, renovate, or customize to your own style. Recent improvements include a cleaned and refreshed deck, yard cleanup that enhances the property's curb appeal, a newly installed exterior electrical service box, and a new septic system—providing a strong foundation for future updates and added peace of mind. Surrounded by towering pines and abundant wildlife, you'll enjoy frequent visits from deer and elk while taking in the serenity of the mountain landscape. The spacious .722-acre lot offers plenty of room for gardens, outdoor entertaining, a fire pit, or simply relaxing and enjoying the fresh mountain air. Whether you're searching for a weekend getaway, an investment property, or a full-time residence with room to make it your own, this cabin is filled with potential. Bring your imagination and transform this hidden gem into the mountain escape you've always dreamed of. Don't miss this opportunity to own an affordable slice of the Sacramento Mountains and make it uniquely yours.

17 Sunflower Trl, Mayhill

$579,300
3 Beds 2 Baths 172564 MLS
Unique & Unrestricted, this spacious 3,332 sq. ft. Mountain Retreat Home offers room for everyone! With 3- bedrooms, 2-baths-recently remodeled with REBATH showers and glass doors, the home uses earth-sheltered construction in the front and skylights throughout for incredible energy efficiency. Two of the bedrooms offer large walk-in closets, one with its own make-up room. The open kitchen with tiled Southwest aesthetic, has been thoughtfully updated with a new fridge and dishwasher making the home a perfect blend of vintage character and modern reliability. It features a breakfast bar as well as room for your favorite dining table and lighted display shelving. The kitchen offers 2 walk-in pantries for maximum storage and stocking up! Relax in the living room by the cozy wood burning stove or step into a massive glass backed 15' atrium with a large Chodzko tile mosaic. The tall windows and skylights flood the interior with sunlight giving you first row seating to the changing seasons. Situated on 2.018 acres of unrestricted land in the beautiful, gated community of Cloud Country Estates, this property is HOA-FREE- a rare find in this community! The home features an attached 2-car garage with finished tile floors. The laundry room boasts plenty of storage, new flooring, a large countertop and many cabinets that could serve as a work area complete with its own entrance. Still not enough space? How about a flex-space for a potential 4th bedroom, game room, shop or craft room- with its own entrance in front of the home. Outside you'll find a 12'x24' shop and lean-to with its own new gravel driveway. The home features a large attic that is accessible from an amazing large walk-in bedroom closet- or through a newly installed a side door. Stay fully powered with a Cummins full-home generator. Enjoy the owned- highly efficient full-home water softener. Sip your morning coffee with beautiful forest views outdoors on the stone paved patio or on the expansive maintenance -free Trex deck wrapping around the back of the atrium as you watch the deer, elk and turkeys on your private acreage. The home features many updates including a remodeled closet in the main bedroom, new Heating and AC units, new mini-split, new gas heater in workshop, a new chimney, new garage door motors and a French drain. This one-of-a-kind home is waiting for you to call it your own.

41 Cloud Country DR, Mayhill

$475,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 172364 MLS
Discover the ultimate mountain lifestyle in this expansive 2674 sq. ft., 4-bedroom, 3.75 bath retreat located within the highly sought-after gated community of Cloud Country Estates. Located just minutes out of Cloudcroft, this mountain home is designed for relaxation and entertaining, spanning three levels of comfort. With one bedroom on the main entry level, 2 bedrooms upstairs and another bedroom on the lower level, privacy is easy to find. As you walk through the home, you'll notice that the home is beautifully decorated and almost all wall decor and furnishings are included! The main floor living room boasts a rustic decorative rock front wood burning fireplace and an amazing elk antler chandelier. The kitchen is spacious with a separate dining area as well as a bar for even more room. In the hallway is a laundry room all set up with a washer, dryer and plenty of storage. Walk upstairs to the main bedroom with a decorative bathroom and a generous walk-in closet with plenty of room for clothing and more! An additional bath located just down the hall features a relaxing soaker tub perfect for unwinding from the day. The lower level is a true getaway featuring a secluded, cozy bedroom accessed by a stunning spiral staircase. Just outside of the bedroom is a sitting area with a convenient wet bar, a bathroom and a spacious game room (pool table is included!) Step outside from the lower level onto a massive Trex deck to enjoy the fresh mountain air and amazing views including deer, elk, turkey and more. Relax while you let your furry friends roam safely in the private, fenced in grassy area. The home comes with peace of mind, featuring a full-home Generac generator, a 2-car detached garage to store your vehicles, side-by-side or use it as a hobby or work area. The home comes almost fully furnished-just bring your suitcase! Cloud Country Estates is a beautiful, well-maintained community offering a secure gated entrance, a pool, tennis/pickleball courts, a stocked fishing pond and a party barn available for your events and parties. Don't miss this incredible deal for a home of this size and location. Call for your showing today!

49 Aspen, Mayhill

$899,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 172326 MLS
Set within the Dark Skies enclave of Mayhill/Cloudcroft, this exceptional 3.4-acre mountain estate offers a rare opportunity to own a purpose-built astronomy retreat bordering the natural beauty of the Lincoln National Forest. Designed for those who value privacy, space, and the extraordinary, this residence seamlessly blends refined mountain living with a truly unique stargazing experience, taking full advantage of one of the region’s most coveted dark sky environments. The lower level welcomes you with ground-level entry and a fully self-contained living space, ideal for guests or extended stays, featuring a secondary kitchen, private office, two bedrooms, a full bath, and a spacious gathering area perfect for entertaining or private relaxation. A covered patio extends the living experience outdoors, offering a peaceful setting surrounded by forest. The upper level reveals the heart of the home, where an inviting living area flows effortlessly into a well-appointed kitchen with granite countertops and generous workspace. A guest bedroom and full bath provide comfort and convenience, while the primary suite offers a private retreat complete with an en-suite bath, expansive walk-in closet, radiant heated floors and tiled walk-in shower. An expansive deck off the main living area captures the essence of mountain living, ideal for quiet mornings, sunset views, and evening gatherings under crisp, star-filled skies. A defining element of this property is its dedicated observatory infrastructure, including both a dome and roll-off structure for telescopes — a rare and highly specialized feature designed for serious enthusiasts and those seeking an unparalleled connection to the night sky. Encompassing 3.4 acres, the property offers a sense of seclusion and scale that is increasingly difficult to find, with direct access to outdoor recreation and the surrounding forest landscape. Opportunities to acquire a property of this caliber, combining acreage, architectural flexibility, and purpose-built astronomy amenities, are exceptionally limited in the Cloudcroft/Mayhill area. This is more than a home; it is a destination, a retreat, and an experience unlike any other. Home also features an in house vacuum and 40 KW whole home generator w/500 gallon propane tank. Don't miss out to view this property in person, Schedule your showing today and check out the 3D virtual tour! https://my.matterport.com/show/?m=ExEQVJkeqKZ&mls=1

33 Joy Rd, Mayhill

$679,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 171668 MLS
Stunning home located in the exquisite Cloud Country Estates. This 3250 square foot home has been well taken care of with new windows installed throughout the house in 2020. Enjoy the fireplace in the family room or entertain guests in the formal living room with vaulted ceilings. The kitchen has a separate breakfast nook, a pantry, an island with a trash compactor, a cooktop, and a double oven. There is also a formal dining area off the formal living room. Enjoy the natural light in the master bedroom with the large private picture window with an added arched window above it. These beautiful windows allow you to relish the multiple pine trees just outside. The master bath has a large garden tub, a separate shower, double sinks, and a private lavatory. The other two bedrooms share a shower but have private lavatories. The office could also be used as a small fourth bedroom if needed. The utility room has lots of cabinets for extra storage. Downstairs boasts a kitchenette, an entertainment room with a door to access the outside. There is a large storage area outside under the deck with a shed to keep items out of the weather. There is also a three-car garage with a storage room. To keep this house running smoothly, there are two hot water heaters with a recirculating pump to keep hot water instantly available. There is also a water softener and a Generac generator that has been serviced annually since it was installed three years ago. The formal living room and family room open up to a large private covered porch to remind you of why you love the mountains! Enjoy the amenities Cloud Country Estates has to offer, including the swimming pool, a pond, tennis/pickle ball courts, and paved roads. This is a one-of-a-kind home just looking for its new owners!! All the furniture is negotiable except for the pictures, antiques, and piano.

17 Wild Cherry, Mayhill

$259,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 171326 MLS
Back on the market due to buyer financing. This home is ready for a cash buyer or financing. The permanent foundation has been inspected by the State of New Mexico, and the green tag is in hand, allowing for deactivation of the manufactured home title and helping streamline the financing process. Nestled on 1.34 acres in the peaceful Robin Hood subdivision, approximately 7 miles east of Cloudcroft, this spacious manufactured home offers the perfect blend of mountain living, comfort, and functionality. Surrounded by the natural beauty of the Lincoln National Forest, you'll enjoy cool mountain temperatures, abundant wildlife, and plenty of room to relax and unwind. Inside, a generous living area welcomes family and friends, highlighted by a cozy pellet stove that creates a warm and comfortable atmosphere on crisp mountain evenings. The spacious kitchen offers abundant cabinetry, countertop space, and room for gathering, making it the ideal place to prepare meals and entertain. The primary suite serves as a private retreat with a walk-in closet, ensuite bathroom, and a jetted soaking tub perfect for relaxing after a day of hiking, exploring, or enjoying the outdoors. Two additional bedrooms and a second full bathroom provide comfortable accommodations for family and guests. Step outside and take in the fresh mountain air from the covered front porch or the expansive covered back deck. Whether you're hosting summer barbecues, enjoying your morning coffee, or watching local wildlife pass through, the outdoor living spaces make the most of the property's beautiful setting. Additional features include a dedicated laundry area, a large two-car carport, a second carport for additional storage, a storage shed, and RV hookups for visiting guests or your own adventures. With over an acre of usable land, there's ample space for gardening, outdoor recreation, or future improvements. If you're looking for a full-time residence, mountain getaway, or weekend retreat with room to spread out and enjoy nature, this property is ready to welcome you home. Schedule your private showing today and be sure to explore the 3D Virtual Tour.

6 Will Scarlet, Mayhill

Start Your Search